Letter sent to The Times, appeared, with minor edits,
Monday 13th December 2010.
As doctors we welcome the news that the Prime Minister has asked Oliver Letwin to review Andrew Lansley’s White paper on health, Equity and Excellence: Liberating the NHS. Rather than “liberating the NHS”, these proposals seem to be an exercise in liberating the NHS’s £100 billion budget to commercial enterprises. We believe they will destroy the NHS as we know it.
The last thing the NHS needs at this time of austerity is another reorganization, (costing up to £3bn according to the Kings Fund), damaging morale and the ability to make decisions about NHS economies based on rational planning rather than market forces.
Andrew Lansley’s aims of putting patients at the heart of care, involving clinicians in decisions about the provision of services and reducing managerial costs could be achieved without the massive structural upheavals of abolishing PCTs and SHAs. PCT Boards could be restructured, to give much better representation of clinicians,. members of the public and accountable members of Local Government. The present, costly healthcare ‘market’ could be abolished, saving billions in transaction costs and achieving the £20 billion ‘efficiency savings’ demanded by Sir David Nicholson.
BMA policy is to uphold the founding principles of the NHS (which are held dear by British citizens) and states that health care should be on the basis of public provision, not private ownership, co-operation, not competition, integration, not fragmentation and public service, not private profits. 4 out of 5 doctors believe the reforms will not benefit patients. The recent Commonwealth Fund (Mass) report found that only 3% of British people thought their health service needed radical restructuring, the lowest proportion of any country studied. With health professionals and the concerned public so opposed to these reforms, it would surely be stubborn folly for the government to impose them.
The final list of signatories is 225 names.
Signatories to Letter to The Times newspaper, published Monday 13th December 2010
Title | First | Surname | Position | |
1. | Dr | Sheila | Abdullah | GP (Retired) |
2. | Dr | Mark | Aitken | Consultant Physician |
3. | Dr | Amina | Aitsi-Selmi | SpR |
4. | Dr | Liz | Anderson | SpR GU Medicine |
5. | Dr | Jackie | Applebee | GP |
6. | Mr | Matthew | Armon | Consultant Geriatrician |
7. | Dr | Natasha | Arnold | Consultant Geriatrician |
8. | Dr | John | Atkins | Consultant in Fetal Medicine (Retired) |
9. | Dr | Ian | Banks | GP, President Mens Health Forum. Member BMA Council |
10. | Dr | Helen | Bantock | Consultant Paediatrician (Retired) |
11. | Dr | David | Bareford | Consultant Haematologist |
12. | Dr | Simon | Barry | Consultant Chest Physician |
13. | Dr | Eric | Beck | Emeritus Physician |
14. | Dr | Morris | Bernadt | Consultant Psychiatrist |
15. | Mr | Michael | Beverley | Consultant Orthopaedic Surgeon |
16. | Dr | Beulah R. | Bewley | Past president MWF |
17. | Mr | John | Beynon | Consultant Consultant O&G (Retired) |
18. | Dr | Christopher | Birt | Consultant in Public Health |
19. | Professor | David | Blane | Professor of Medical Sociology |
20. | Dr | Lynda | Bobrow FRCPath | Consultant Histopathologist (Retired) |
21. | Dr | Kambiz | Boomla | Senior Lecturer in GP |
22. | Dr | Robert | Boon | Consultant paediatrician |
23. | Dr | David | Bramble | Consultant Child Psychiatrist |
24. | Ms | Helene | Brandon | Consultant O&G |
25. | Dr | David | Broughton | Clinical director medicine for Older People |
26. | Dr | Joan | Brown | Consultant Anaesthetist (Retired) |
27. | Dr | Raymond | Brown | Consultant Paediatrician |
28. | Mr | Hamish | Brown | Consultant Breast Surgeon |
29. | Dr | Peter | Bruggen | Psychiatrist (Retired) |
30. | Dr | Nick | Burns-Cox | Consultant Urologist |
31. | Dr | Ann | Capewell | Consultant Physician/Clinical Director of medicine for Older people |
32. | Dr | Peter | Carter | Cons. Psychiatrist |
33. | Sir | Iain | Chalmers | Editor James Lind Library Epidemiologist(retired) |
34. | Professor | N.Ann | Chamberlain | Consultant Rehab Med (Retired) |
35. | Dr | Kailash | Chand OBE | Chair Tameside and Glossop NHS |
36. | Dr | Rajiv | Chandy | Consultant Physician & Gastroenterologist |
37. | Professor | Imti | Choonara | Professor of Child Health |
38. | Dr | Alice | Clack | Consultant |
39. | Dr | Charles | Clarke FRCP | Consultant Physician |
40. | Miss | Jane | Cockburn FRCOG | Consultant O&G |
41. | Professor | Peter | Crome | Geriatric Medicine |
42. | Dr | Robert | Cumming | Haemotologist (Retired) |
43. | Dr | Jack | Czauderna | GP |
44. | Dr | Jonathan | Dare | Consultant Child Psychiatrist (Ret) |
45. | Dr | Jonathan | Darling | Sen.Lect.&Hon.Cons.inPaed.&ChildHlth |
46. | Dr | Gerry | Davies | Senior Lecturer in Infectious Diseases |
47. | Dr | Melanie | Davies | Past president MWF Consultant O&G |
48. | Dr | Susan | Davies | Consultant Pathologist |
49. | Dr | Jacky | Davis | Consultant Radiologist |
50. | Dr | R.S. | Delamont | Consultant Neurologist |
51. | Lecturer | Nick | Dennis | Snr Lecturer Clinical Genetics, South Hampton (Retired) |
52. | Miss | Jane | Dickinson | Consultant Opthalmologist |
53. | Emeritus Professor | John | Dickinson | Professor of Medicine (Retired) |
54. | Dr | Paolo | Domizio | Consultant Pathologist |
55. | Dr | Jo | Downton | Consultant in Rehabilitation Medicine |
56. | Professor | Christopher | Dowrick BA MSc MC CQSW FRCGO FFPHM | Professor of Primary Medical care |
57. | Dr | Tim | Dowson | GP |
58. | Dr | Peter | Draper | Public Health (Retired) |
59. | Dr | Matthew | Dunnigan | Senior Research Fellow |
60. | Dr | Mary | Edmondson | GP |
61. | Dr | Peter | Ehrhardt FRCP FRCPCH | Consultant Paediatrician |
62. | Dr. | Maggie | Eisner | Training Programme Dir.for GPs |
63. | Dr | Robert | Elkeles | Professor of Diabetic Medicine |
64. | Dr | D.M. | Eminson FRCPsych | Retd.Cons. Child&Adolescent Psychiatrist |
65. | Professor | Anneez | Esmail | Professor of GP |
66. | Dr | Chris | Evans | GP |
67. | Dr | Clarissa | Fabre | President of MWF and GP |
68. | Mr | Barry | Fairbrother FRCS | Consultant Surgeon (Retired) |
69. | Dr | Catriona | Farell | Radiology Registrar |
70. | Mr | Barry | Fearn FRCS | Orthopeadic Sirgeon (retired) |
71. | Mr | John | Feehally | Nephrologist |
72. | Dr | Tim | Fenn | GP |
73. | Dr | Jacqui | Ferguson | Psychotherapist and Psychoanalyst |
74. | Dr | Veronica | Fisher | GP Retired |
75. | Dr | Fleur | Fisher | Family Planning doctor and manager. Pst president of MWF. Former BMA spokesperson (retired) |
76. | Dr | Peter | Fisher | Consultant Physician (retired) |
77. | Dr | Roger A | Fisken | Retired Consultant Physician |
78. | Dr | Richard | Fitzgerald | Consultant Radiologist |
79. | Professor | Peter | Fleming CBE | Professor of paediatrics |
80. | Dr | Jonathan | Fluxman | GP |
81. | Dr | Andrea | Franks | Consultant Dermatologist |
82. | Professor. | Geoff | Gill | Aintree University Hospital |
83. | Professor | Steve | Goodacre | Professor of Emergency Medicine |
84. | Dr | Michael | Gopfert | Cons. Child & Adolescent Psychiatrist |
85. | Emeritus Professor | Isky | Gordon FRCR FRCP | Consultant Oncologist (Retired) |
86. | Dr | Derek | Gould | Consultant interventional Radiologist. NIHR Senior Investigator |
87. | Dr | Elizabeth | Greenhall | FP specialist head of Oxford FP |
88. | Dr | Roger | Greenwood | Consultant |
89. | Dr | Helen | Groom | Vice chair of MPU & GP |
90. | Dr | Richard | Grunewald | Consultant Neurologist |
91. | Dr | Richard | Gunstone | Physician (Retired) |
92. | Dr | Alyson | Hall | Hon Consultant Child & Adolescent Psychiatrist, |
93. | Mr | David | Halpin FRCS | Consultant Orthopaedic Surgeon |
94. | Dr | Gervase | Hamilton | (Retired). Consultant in Public Health Med. |
95. | Dr | AM | Hamlyn FRCP | Consultant in Public Health Med. |
96. | Dr | N.G. | Harrington | Consultant Geriatrician |
97. | Dr | Evan | Harris | Fromer GP and MP |
98. | Dr | David | Hawkins FRCP | Consultant Physician |
99. | Dr | Roger | Hayter | Consultant Physician |
100. | Dr | Keith | Hertogs | GP |
101. | Dr | Julia | Hodges | GP |
102. | Dr | Wren | Hoskyns | Consultant Paediatrician |
103. | Dr | Trevor A. | Howlett | Consultant Physician |
104. | Dr | David | Hughes | Consultant Radiologist |
105. | Dr | Louise | Irvine | GP |
106. | Professor | William | Irving | Hon Consultant Virology |
107. | Dr | Samina | Ishaq | Lead Consultant Acute Pain Service |
108. | Dr | Penelope | Jarrett | GP |
109. | Dr | Liz | Joekes | Consultant Radiologist |
110. | Dr | Chris | Jones | Chair of exec board Bro Taf local health group |
111. | Dr | Melanie | Jones | Consultant Anesthetist Past President of MWF |
112. | Dr | Sally | Jowett | GP |
113. | Dr | Shazid | Karim | GP |
114. | Professor | Harry | Keen CBE MD FRCP | Professor of medicine |
115. | Dr | Jessica | Kirker | Consultant Psychiatrist in Psychotherapy |
116. | Dr | Hillary | Klorin | Consultant Paediatrician |
117. | Dr | Sebastian | Kramer | Consultant Child & Adolescent Psychiatrist |
118. | Dr | Alan | Lee | Consultant Psychiatrist |
119. | Dr | Dianne | Lefevre FRCP FRCPsych | Consultant Psychiatrist |
120. | Dr | Richard | Lehman | Sen.Research Fellow,Dept.Primary Care |
121. | Dr | Geoffrey | Lewis | Consultant anaesthetist |
122. | Dr | Karen | Leyden | Consultant anaesthetist |
123. | Dr | Anna Eleri | Livingstone | GP |
124. | Dr | M.R. | Lowe | Consultant Psychiatrist |
125. | Dr | N.C. | Lowe | GP |
126. | Dr | Robert | MacGibbon FRCGP | GP Retired |
127. | Dr | Heather | Mackinnon | Consultant Paediatrician |
128. | Dr | Anthony | Macklon | Consultant Physician |
129. | Dr | John | Main | Consultant Nephrologist |
130. | Dr | Jane | Mann | GP |
131. | Dr | Pam | Martin | GP |
132. | Dr | Cath | McGrother | Consultant in Public Health Medicine |
133. | Dr | Helena | McKeown FRCGP. | GP |
134. | Dr | Diana | Menzies | Consultant Psychiatirst in Psychotherapy |
135. | Emeritus Professor | David | Metcalfe OBE | Professor of General Practice |
136. | Dr | Penny | Milner | GP |
137. | Dr | David | Misselbrook | Dean Royal society of Medicine |
138. | Dr | Geoff | Mitchell | Consultant Psychiatrist (Retired) |
139. | Dr | Sally | Mitchison | Consultant Psychiatirst in Psychotherapy |
140. | Dr | M I | Morcos | GP |
141. | Dr | Pat | Munday | Consultant Genitourinary Physician |
142. | Dr | Julia | Nelki | Consultant in Child Psychiatry |
143. | Dr | Elizabeth | Nevrkla | Consultant Paediatrician (Retired) |
144. | Dr | Elizabeth | Newson | GP |
145. | Dr | Helen | Newton FRCP | Locum Consultant in Rehabilitation |
146. | Dr | Malila | Noone | Consultant Microbiologist (retired) |
147. | Dr | Tiz | North | Consultant Radiologist & Chair Merton & Sutton BMA Division |
148. | Dr | Susan | O’Halloran | Retired Consultant Paediatrician |
149. | Dr | Geraldine | O’Hara | Research Fellow/SpR Medicine |
150. | Dr | Kevin | O’Kane | Consultant Physician & hair BMA London Regional Council |
151. | Dr | Ellie | O’Sullivan | Consultant anaesthetist member of BMA CCSC |
152. | Dr | P | O’Sullivan | GP |
153. | Lord | Walton | of Detchant | Previous president of GMC Consultant Physician (retired) |
154. | Dr | Stephen | Olczak | Cons.Physician in Endoc. & Diabetes |
155. | Mr | David | Paintin FRCOG | Emeritus Reader in O&G |
156. | Dr | Jacqueline | Payne | GP |
157. | Dr | Clive | Peedell | Consultant Oncologist BMA Council |
158. | Miss | Audrey | Platt FRCOG | Consultant O&G (Retired) |
159. | Dr | Janet | Porter | Consultant Accident & Emergency |
160. | Professor | Neil | Pride | Emeritus Professor in respiratory medicine |
161. | Dr | John | Puntis | Consultant Paediatrician |
162. | Dr | I.F. | Pye | Consultant Neurologist |
163. | Lord | Nic | Rea | GP (Retired) |
164. | Dr | Merriel | Reid | GP |
165. | Dr | Gerard | Reissmann | GP |
166. | Mr | Bryan | Rhodes | Consultant Orthopaedic Surgeon |
167. | Dr | Kate | Richards | GP (Retired) |
168. | Dr | Russell | Roberts | Consultant Nephrologist |
169. | Dr | Sarah | Robertson | Consultant psychiatrist in psychotherapy |
170. | Dr | Andrew | Robins | Consultant Paediatrician |
171. | Dr | John | Robson | GP |
172. | Dr | Tony | Roques | Consultant Haematologist (Retired) |
173. | Dr | Donna | Samuels | GP |
174. | Professor | David | Sanders | Hon Professor Gastroenterology |
175. | Professor | Wendy | Savage | Past president of MWF. SL O&G (retired) |
176. | Dr | Brian | Scott MD FRCP | Consultant Physician |
177. | Dr | Alex | Scott-Samuel | Senior Clinical Lecturer |
178. | Dr | Jim | Sikorski | GP |
179. | Dr | Brian | Silk | Consult.Padiatrician, Med.Dir. (Retired) |
180. | Dr | Ron | Singer | GP |
181. | Dr | Surinder | Singh | GP |
182. | Professor | Alan | Smyth | Professor of Child health |
183. | Dr | Ann | Solomon | GP |
184. | Dr | Nigel | Speight | Consultant Paediatrician |
185. | Dr | S.Bertel | Squire | ? Public Health |
186. | Dr | Fiona | Subotsky | Past President MWF/retired Child Psychiatrist |
187. | Dr | John | Sweeney | Consultant Physician Sexual Health |
188. | Dr | R.L. | Symonds | Consultant Psychiatrist |
189. | Dr | Patricia | Tate | GP |
190. | Emeritus Professor | Ron | Taylor | Professor of O&G (Retired) |
191. | Dr | Richard | Taylor | Consultant Physician ex-MP (Retired) |
192. | Dr | David | Taylor Robinson | MRC Population Health Scientist |
193. | Dr | Katherine | Teale | Consultant anaesthetist |
194. | Dr | Kathrin | Thomas | GP & Public Health |
195. | Dr | Sarah | Thurlbeck | Consultant Paediatrician |
196. | Dr | John | Tomkinson | Consultant Psychiatrist |
197. | Dr | Jonathon | Tomlinson | GP |
198. | Professor | David | Tomlinson | Faculty of Life Sciences |
199. | Dr | Mike | Tomson | GP |
200. | Dr | Dave | Tomson FRCGP | GP |
201. | Baroness | Jenny | Tonge | Family Planning doctor (retired) |
202. | Dr | Norman | Traub | ConsultantHaematologist (Retired) |
203. | Dr | John | Tripp | Consultant Paediatrician (Retired) |
204. | Dr | Carol | Trotter | Consultant in Old Age Psychiatry |
205. | Dr | Julian | Tudor-Hart | GP, author & research fellow |
206. | Dr | Gill | Turner | Consultant Paediatrician |
207. | Mr | Rick | Turnock | Consultant Paediatric Surgeon |
208. | Dr | Nadja | van Ginnekin | GP Locum |
209. | Dr | Helen | Venning | Consultant Paediatric and Adolescent Rheumatologist |
210. | Dr | Paul | Walker | Public health Editor Health Matters Retired |
211. | Dr | Lucy | Walker | MRC Research Training Fellow |
212. | Dr | Bill | Ward | GP |
213. | Dr | Martin | Wastie | Consultant radiologist |
214. | Dr | Tony | Waterston | Consultant Paediatrician (Retired) |
215. | Dr | Malcolm | Weller | Consultant Psychiatrist Adult & Neropsychiatry |
216. | Dr | Diana | Wellesley | Consultant/Hon Senior Llecturer in Genetics |
217. | Dr | A.J. | Wills | Consultant Neurologist |
218. | Dr | Barrie | Woodcock | Consultant Haematologist |
219. | Dr | Pam | Wortley | GP |
220. | Sir | Nicholas | Wright | Warden Barts& the London Medical School Pathologist |
221. | Dr | David | Wrigley | GP, member BMA Council &GPC |
222. | Emeritus Professor | John S | Yudkin MD FRCP | Professor of Diabetic Medicine |
223. | Dr | Luke | Zander | GP(retired) |
224. | Dr | Patrick | Zentler-Munro | Consultant Physician |
225. | Dr | Pam | Zinkin | Consultant Paediatrician (Retired) |
The Editor
The Financial Times
8th December 2010
Dear Editor
Most of my fellow professionals and even more of my fellow citizens share very serious concerns about this Coalition Government’s plans for the NHS, revealed in Andrew Lansley’s health White Paper, ‘Equity and excellence: liberating the NHS’ . Government has just postponed its progress until 2011. Very many of us feel that it should be entirely abandoned. The NHS is funded from the public purse and delivered by dedicated and experienced staff. Their views about major developments of the NHS have been ignored.
Despite pre-election assurances of “no more top-down NHS reorganisations”, respected health observers describe the Coalition proposals as the biggest shake up of the NHS since its inception. They were produced without public or professional discussion and have had insufficient testing There are practical, financial and social dangers in the implementation of this unmandated upheaval and a renewed sense of public anxiety about NHS adequacy. .
It has been credibly estimated that the act of restructuring alone will cost over £3 billion, an untimely and utterly unnecessary expense. NHS staff dismissed from primary care trusts and strategic health authorities will receive generous redundancy compensation and then may be re-employed by the new GP commissioning consortia. Beyond the ‘reorganisation’ costs, it has been estimated that running the new system is likely to cost £1.2 billion a year more than currently. Duplication and bureaucracy will encumber the disintegrated service when 500 or so GP consortia try to do the job of the 152 current PCTs.
These totally untested and enormously expensive destructurings of the NHS are to be made at a time when it is required to deliver £20 billion of efficiency savings in the face of falling real buying power. Inevitably there will be job losses, disrupted services, hospital closures, deteriorations that government will blame on the economic crisis.
Crucially, the policies will have a major impact on public perceptions of the NHS. GPs will be seen as responsible for economies and cuts. The priceless bond of trust between doctor and patient will be eroded if the GP is held responsible for commissioning decisions that deny a hospital referral, an expensive test or a costly treatment. Uncoordinated commissioning will lead to great locality variation in provision resulting in a postcode lottery far greater than anything seen before. Treatments available to one patient may be denied to a next door neighbour with a different GP. There will be “no bail-outs for organisations which overspend public budgets”.
The very widely expressed sceptical response to the Coalition’s ill-considered proposals cannot be dismissed as simple ‘resistance to change’ or ideologically driven. Criticism has come from pro-market think-tank Civitas, the respected King’s Fund, the internationally renowned Lancet journal, the NHS Confederation, the Nuffield Institute and even the reserved and cautious Royal Colleges.
Only sustained, concerted and well argued resistance will deflect the Coalition from a course which profoundly threatens not only the equitable and progressive development of the NHS but also the government’s claim to found changes on a sound evidence base. The NHS must evolve. Let it do so on the basis of changing human needs, clinical discovery and rational resource management rather than in pursuit of political dogma.
Yours sincerely
Harry Keen
Professor Harry Keen CBE MD FRCP
President, NHS Support Federation
Emeritus Professor of Human Metabolism and Consultant Physician
Guy’s Hospital Campus, King’s College London
Hon Professor Warwick University Medical School
Pingback: NHS Reforms: Black Wednesday | Abetternhs's Blog
Pingback: Labours gift to Lansley | Abetternhs's Blog